The alternative to surrogate keys is natural data keys. Difference between a primary key and a surrogate key. Surrogate keys are also less expensive to join fewer columns to. Perhaps the best way to describe this surrogate key architecture is with an example database. Surrogate keys tend to be a compact data type, such as a fourbyte integer. Surrogate key are never populated with null values. Surrogate keys are usually just simple sequential numbers where each number uniquely identifies a row. Its typically not used anymore, as it typically poses more problems than it solves.
The reality is that natural and surrogate keys each have their advantages and. Generating surrogate keys to generate surrogate keys, add a surrogate key generator stage to a. In this tip we cover the pros and cons to using a surrogate key vs natural key. Transforming your data using surrogate keys oracle docs. Sql database refactoring techniques replacing a natural key. Apr 28, 2019 a natural key is a primary key made from the normal natural data you store. I do realize it was titled with sql server with my limited but growing knowledge in regards i didnt think that it would matter if it was an article for oracle, sql server nosql, mysql, etc. What name can you give the surrogate key column in a database table when the convention suggested name collides with that of an existing user field business key for example, if i am creating a product table and productid is already used and known by that name in the company, bussinesswise. Outside of the system, an address id has no value to anyone. Use the surrogate key as the primary key for the moment. Because surrogate keys are systemgenerated, it is impossible for the system to create and store a duplicate value. A column or group of columns in a table which helps us to uniquely identifies every row in that table is called a primary key. Surrogate keys are simple numeric values, as simple as normal counting.
In my 25 years experience with warehouses, i created databases with and without surrogate keys. Preparing data in oracle business intelligence cloud service. As soon as the business uses the surrogate key to uniquely identify and track data in the source system, the surrogate key becomes a business key. In order to understand the many substantial benefits of surrogate keys its necessary to discuss some background on the issues involved.
The difference between a primary key and surrogate key. This means the surrogate key generator allocates keys each time a job is run. Thatys a great definition for the surrogate keys we use in data warehouses. How to generate sequences and surrogate keys in generic sql. Sep 11, 2012 surrogate keys also provide uniformity and compatibility. Some say that a natural data key system has the advantage of inherent enforcement of referential integrity. Dbms keys allow you to establish a relationship between and identify the relation between tables. The surrogate key value is the result of a program, which creates the systemgenerated value. The first five letters of the last name concatenated with the date of birth. It is a unique key whose only significance is to act as the primary identifier of an object or entity and is not derived from any other data in the database and may or may not be used as the primary key. If you are using several different database application development systems, drivers, and objectrelational mapping systems it can be simpler to use an integer for surrogate keys for every table instead of natural keys to support objectrelational mapping.
However, they are not good candidates for a business key if the business itself is not using them. A natural key is a primary key made from the normal natural data you store. The literature speaks of both natural and surrogate keys and gives reasons for choosing one over the. Generating surrogate keys to generate surrogate keys, add a surrogate key generator stage to a job with a single output link to another stage. If a natural key is recommended, use a surrogate key field as the primary key, and a natural key as a foreign key. As mentioned, a surrogate key sacrifices some of the original context of the data. If you polled any number of sql server database professionals and. Software developers often use surrogate keys to business users to identify records. A table could actually have more than one surrogate key. A surrogate key can be a system generated sequence number or a combination of parts of a column that serve to make the row unique. In case of combined natural primary keys join operations can became very complex.
However, it can be extremely useful for analytical purposes for the following reasons. Since these columns are attributes of the entity they obviously have business meaning. Natural key in database programmer and software interview. A super key is a group of single or multiple keys which identifies rows in a table.
The surrogate key is not derived from application data, unlike a natural or business key which is. For example, sybase and sql server both have whats called an identity column specifically meant to hold a unique sequential number for each row. But for the database, its used to uniquely identify the record. The surrogate will be the primary a key and the natural key will have a unique index based on it, making it a business key that will be used for searches. Apr 10, 2014 a surrogate key is a primary key that was introduced to identify entities within the database and which is not used by the users of the database to identify these entities in their view of the world. Surrogate keys also provide uniformity and compatibility. Surrogate keys are often used when there is no other. Use data sync to improve performance by creating surrogate keys. As surrogate keys are simple and short, it speedup the join performance. Object relational mapping orm frameworks such as entity framework, nhibernate, and so on are designed to work optimally with surrogate keys.
A surrogate key is frequently a sequential number e. Performance evaluation of natural and surrogate key database. If your database doesnt support this well, then you are right in avoiding natural keys. A primary key can be either a single column using a surrogate meaningless number a. Surrogate key or a column or set of columns that have meaning to the user and uniquely identify a row in a table natural key. Seven types of dbms keys are super, primary, candidate, alternate, foreign, compound, composite, and surrogate key. Biggest con is that you cannot humanly read any data, and for every action, you need to construct complex queries. Database design for relational databases using sql server udemy. You will not be able to know the meaning of that row of data based on the surrogate key value.
Given modern hardware and software, its not that much trouble to use. A surrogate key is a primary key that was introduced to identify entities within the database and which is not used by the users of the database to identify these entities in. Furthermore, a nonredundant distribution of keys causes the resulting btree index to be completely balanced. End users should not see a surrogate key in a report. Data warehouse surrogate keys are sequentially generated meaningless numbers associated with each and every record in the data warehouse. Jul 22, 2005 data partitioning and surrogate keys in designing a database with oracle partitioning in mind, would it be advisable to create surrogate keys or is it better to remain with the original modelled primary key and create data partitions on the unique key which is the modelled primary key. While users may interact with the natural key, the database can still have surrogate keys outside of the users view, with no interruption to user experience.
A surrogate key is an artificial or synthetic key that is used as a substitute for a natural key. A surrogate key is any column or set of columns that can be declared as the primary key instead of a real or natural key. A surrogate key in a database is a unique identifier for either an entity in the modeled world or. Surrogate keys are usually numeric id values and often used for performance reasons. Surrogate keys are only used to act as a primary key. An example of a surrogate key is an address id for a table of addresses. By the yagni principle, you should only code for reallife current requirements a primary key that may or may not arrive in 5 years is not worth considering now. In every table ive designed in the last few years, ive used a surrogate key. Sometimes there can be several natural keys that could be declared as the primary key, and these are all called candidate keys. If the state file does not exist, you can optionally create it in the same job. When the job is run the next time, the key range from 1001 to 2000 is allocated. With natural keys, all tables and possibly other, related software that use the natural key will have to change. Surrogate keys should primarily be added because they provide you a uniform way for building your primary keys, not because of any hypothetical performance issues. Surrogate keys can be generated in a variety of ways, and most databases offer ways to generate surrogate keys.
With help of surrogate keys, you can integrate heterogeneous data sources to data warehouse if they dont have natural or business keys. So the advantages of surrogate keys are less typing when youve got joins across compound keys and the supposed ability to handle a change of natural key. If a natural key must be used without an additional surrogate key, be. We received answers from five software companies and five independent. Data partitioning and surrogate keys in designing a database with oracle partitioning in mind, would it be advisable to create surrogate keys or is it better to remain with the original modelled primary key and create data partitions on the unique key which is the modelled primary key. They will help you to avoid having business data like an isbn distributed over half of your model in separate places because you misuse them as foreign keys.
When natural keys become available, make them nonnullable unique constraints. In most databases, surrogate keys are only used to act as a primary key. Using a surrogate key is advantageous because it is quicker to join on a numeric field rather than a nonnumeric field. Best thing is that same pattern of surrogate keys can be used across. A natural key is a column or set of columns that already exist in the table e. Surrogate keys have numeric data types, which provide excellent. Some databases provide uuidguid as a possible data type for surrogate keys e. Well discard the first advantage because maintaining surrogate keys isnt free so the actual amount of work saved is hard to calculate. When designing a database to support applications you need to consider how you are going to handle primary keys.
Surrogate key in sql server community of software and data. Surrogate keys are often used in data warehousing systems, as the high data volume in a data warehouse means that optimizing query speed becomes important. To update the state file, add a surrogate key generator stage to a job with a single input link from another stage. Surrogate key vs natural key differences and when to use in. Weve created some tables, each one has a few columns. An artificial key made from data that is system assigned or generated when another candidate key exists. If users can get to the surrogate key, they will screw up the data integrity by getting the real keys and these physical locators out of synch. For example, in sql server or sybase database system contain an artificial key that is known as identity. Best thing is that same pattern of surrogate keys can be used across all the tables present in a starschema. Database administrators stack exchange is a question and answer site for database professionals who wish to improve their database skills and learn from others in the community.
A separate question asked participants to comment on the use of surrogate keys. It appears that the vast majority of databases using surrogate keys already follow rule 3, so all i have done is document current practice. Apr 20, 2006 the first problem is inherently caused by inserting meaningless data, and is always a problem, even with the builtin surrogate keys where the rdbms provides a mechanism to retrieve the value. This allows the database to query the single key column faster than it could multiple columns. Surrogate key is an artificial key that is used to uniquely identify the record in table. Database design for relational databases using sql server 4. These surrogate keys are used to join dimension and fact tables usually, database sequences are used to generate surrogate key so it is always unique number surrogate keys cannot be nulls. Surrogate keys are often considered very bad practice, for a variety of good reasons i wont discuss here.
Sep 16, 2007 if users can get to the surrogate key, they will screw up the data integrity by getting the real keys and these physical locators out of synch. If the number of records processed is less than, the highest value that was last used is. Codd wrote that database users may cause the system to generate or delete a surrogate, but they have no control over its. The relationship between any two tables is simple and consistent in sql code expressions. Nov 28, 2019 a surrogate key is frequently a sequential number e. A surrogate key or synthetic key, entity identifier, systemgenerated key, database sequence number, factless key, technical key, or arbitrary unique identifier citation needed in a database is a unique identifier for either an entity in the modeled world or an object in the database. A definite design and programming aspect of working with databases is built on the concept that all keys will be supported by the use surrogate keys. I create a new identifier column in every table, and use a builtin database feature to ensure this is unique. This article explores natural and surrogate keys, and discusses the pros and cons of each, allowing you to determine what makes the best sense in your environment when you are designing your databases. Introduction ch impor oosing a primary key is really tant because it affects the database at the performance and usability levels. Surrogate key vs natural key differences and when to use in sql. Surrogate key while not really a type of key, this refers to a pk that uses a singlecolumn primary key of numeric data. Pdf performance evaluation of natural and surrogate key. Surrogate keys are often used by operational systems to identify the business object.
Below are some of advantages of using surrogate keys in data warehouse. The first problem is inherently caused by inserting meaningless data, and is always a problem, even with the builtin surrogate keys where the rdbms provides a mechanism to retrieve the value. For example, sybase and sql server both have whats called an identity column specifically meant to. Intelligent natural keys versus surrogate blind keys posted on march 8, 2008 by mikewitters 4 comments im not a data architect or dba, but in my current and past positions i, like most software developers, have been responsible for designing schemas for both simple and complex databases. Ask tom natural key as primary key vs surrogate key.
Surrogate keys are often used when there is no other way to identify a record when there is no natural key. Also, using a surrogate key may increase performance because a large natural key can degrade database performance, and due to a fact that surrogate keys are usually integer values a smaller index on a primary key will have better performance on join operations. Apr 30, 2020 dbms keys allow you to establish a relationship between and identify the relation between tables. When and how to use surrogate keys in data modeling l sisense. Schema design using surrogate key oracle community. This in effect naturalizes the key and thereby negates some of the advantages of surrogate keys. He develops utility software as a hobby, including a large collection of sql server utilities. A surrogate key is a unique identifier used in databases for a modeled entity or an object. According to the websters unabridged dictionary, a surrogate is an artificial or synthetic product that is used as a substitute for a natural product. As soon as you display the value of a surrogate key to your end users, or worse yet allow them to work with the value perhaps to search, you have effectively given the key business meaning. This is because i feel the advantages of a surrogate key outweigh the disadvantages. Jan 31, 2011 a definite design and programming aspect of working with databases is built on the concept that all keys will be supported by the use surrogate keys. Performance evaluation of natural and surrogate key database architectures 7 b r f, where f is the blocking factor, given as f b l. It was just an article i ran across when researching surrogate keys vs.
248 957 763 1105 501 817 245 1248 121 772 982 1019 1482 1301 856 1368 45 886 591 1115 401 1127 1528 735 561 615 825 1641 578 1290 32 61 296 1072 786 134 1050 450 138 955 1012 716 1416 516 520 408 806 587 1314 56